About 5 Star Cards
5 Star Cards is a Wisconsin-based sports and trading card company helping collectors grade, consign, and sell their cards with confidence.
Who We Are
Based in Oconomowoc, Wisconsin, 5 Star Cards was built by collectors, for collectors. We know how much your cards mean to you — that's why we treat every submission with the care, transparency, and attention it deserves, from the moment it arrives to the day it sells.
What We Do
- Professional Grading Submissions: We handle the entire grading process with the industry's leading graders — PSA, SGC, and CGC — so you get authenticated, professionally graded cards without the hassle.
- Consignment: Let us sell your cards for you. Our consignment program lists your cards where the right buyers are looking, so you get top value with none of the work.
- Premium eBay Selling: With a trusted eBay presence and a large, engaged audience, we market your cards to serious collectors and maximize your return.
Why Collectors Choose Us
- Transparent tracking of your submissions from intake to payout.
- Fair, competitive consignment terms and reliable weekly payouts.
- Real card people who understand the hobby and communicate every step of the way.
Visit Us
203 E Wisconsin Ave, Suite 203COconomowoc, WI 53066
Get in Touch
Have questions or ready to send in your cards? We'd love to hear from you.
- 📧 Email: matt@5starcards.com