Consign With a Power Seller
Your cards deserve the reach of a top-tier eBay store. We list, sell, and handle everything — you get paid.
Consignment Rates
Competitive payouts with no PayPal fees. The more your card sells for, the more you keep.
| Sold Price | You Receive |
|---|---|
| Under $10 | $3 flat fee |
| $10 to $49.99 | 82% |
| $50 to $99.99 | 84% |
| $100 to $199.99 | 85% |
| $200 to $499.99 | 86% |
| $500 to $999.99 | 87% |
| $1000 to $2999.99 | 88% |
| $3000 to $4999.99 | 90% |
| $5000 to $8999.99 | 92% |
| $9000 plus | 93% |
| No PayPal Fees Involved | |
How Consignment Works
Submit Your Order
Fill out the consignment form on our website with details about the cards you'd like to sell.
Ship Your Cards
Send your graded or raw cards to our Wisconsin facility. We'll confirm receipt and begin processing.
We List & Sell
We photograph your cards, create optimized eBay listings, and sell them through our store with 16K+ followers and 306K+ items sold.
You Get Paid
After the card sells, you receive your payout — up to 93% of the sold price with no PayPal fees involved.
Why Consign With 5 Star Cards?
Maximum Exposure
As a power eBay seller with over 16,000 followers and "Direct from Brand" status, your cards reach a large, active audience of collectors and buyers.
Professional Listings
We handle professional photography, listing creation, and optimized titles. Our 99.9% positive feedback reputation helps your cards sell faster and at better prices.
Full-Service Selling
We take care of everything — listing, shipping to buyers, customer service, and returns. You just send your cards and get paid when they sell.
Frequently Asked Questions
